By-Naresh

The Kerala High Court has held that a claim for the protection of personal information based on the right to privacy cannot co-exist in an Open Court justice system.

Right To Be Forgotten| Protection Of Personal Information Cannot Co-Exist In Open Court Justice System: Kerala HC
Right To Be Forgotten| Protection Of Personal Information Cannot Co-Exist In Open Court Justice System: Kerala HC

Court said the Open Court justice system is a fundamental aspect of a democratic ecosystem such as India and its mere extension in a digital space cannot itself be called violative of privacy rights, in the absence of any law laid down in this regard by the Parliament. The court was dealing with a batch of petitions raising grievances against the publication of the judgments/orders in respective cases by Indian Kanoon and other law journals putting personal information of the petitioners/respondents in public domain which could be accessed through Google.

While stating that it caused them substantial prejudice, mental trauma and agony, the petitioners argued that digital eternity in retaining judgments in the digital domain forever is violative of the fundamental right to be forgotten. The bench was to essentially adjudicate whether in writ petitions pertaining to family matters, a party can seek an order to mask his/her name and address in the cause title and the body of the judgment in order to protect his/her right to privacy.

The division bench of Justice A Muhamed Mustaque and Justice Shoba Annamma Eapen held that the right to be forgotten can only apply retrospectively, on information that has already been disclosed, rather than being claimed to mask information ex-ante. “The right to be forgotten cannot be claimed in current proceedings or in a proceedings of recent origin and it is for the Legislature to fix grounds for the invocation of such a right,” the bench declared.

It stressed that the modern government will have to solve many issues pertaining to the legal ecosystem, on the assimilation of data with different stakeholders focusing on governance, welfare and the common good of the citizens. However, the bench clarified that having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case and duration involved, the court may permit a party to invoke the right to be forgotten to de-index and to remove the personal information from internet search engines.

It added that the court, in appropriate cases, is also entitled to invoke principles related to the right to erasure to allow a party to erase and delete personal data that is available online. Apart from that, the bench declared and held that in family and matrimonial cases and also in other cases where the law does not recognise the Open Court system, the Registry of the Court shall not publish or allow to be published the personal information of the parties on the website or on any other information system maintained by the Court if the parties to such litigation so insist.

While adjudicating the issue which was referred to it by a single-judge bench, the division bench remarked, “With the advancement of technology, the identity of the individual in virtual public space has become digitally immortal and in a liberal and democratic system, the Court cannot claim a monopoly over the data available with the judiciary.”

The bench added that the courts have not formed any policy on open data and the larger public interest compels the judiciary to share data with the public, stakeholders, researchers, government etc. Regarding publication of judgments/orders, the bench said that it is a part of freedom of speech and expression. “The Courtroom is open to all. The Court cannot gloss over the protection available to publishers of judgments under Article 19(1)(a) of our Constitution. Reporting and publishing judgments are part of freedom of speech and expression and that cannot be taken away lightly without the aid of law,” the bench said.

The bench has, however, directed the Registrar of the High Court to publish the privacy notices within two months in both English and Malayalam languages on the websites of the High Court and the District Judiciary.

 
Related Posts
Turkey once again struck by earthquake, cracks in Indian Army hospital
Strong earthquake tremors have been felt once again in Turkey, which is moaning due to the fierce attack of nature. The tremors of the earthquake on Monday evening were so ...
READ MORE
In Cuttack, a stepmother murders her 2-year-old child and hangs herself.
A married woman's body was discovered hanging in her home in the Sriram Nagar area of Cuttack's Madhupatna police station on Monday. The body of her two-year-old stepson was also ...
READ MORE
'Bhabiji Ghar Par Hain' fame Saumya Tandon was filled with vermilion by a boy, the actress revealed
Saumya Tandon of the famous TV show 'Bhabiji Ghar Par Hai' fame is known for her on-point comic style and amazing fashion sense. Saumya has enthralled the audience by playing ...
READ MORE
Sukesh Chandrasekhar ruined my life, ruined my career, Jacqueline Fernandez gave a statement
Bollywood actress Jacqueline Fernandez is in constant headlines for her personal life. The difficulties of the 200 crore money laundering case of the actress are not taking its name. Due ...
READ MORE
Assam CM Sarma said – More than 4000 cases have been registered against child marriage, action will start from February 3.
To curb child marriage, the Assam government is gearing up and continuous action is being taken against it. On Thursday, state Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma tweeted that the Assam ...
READ MORE
Be careful if you see these symptoms in winter! There may be a risk of brain stroke
Even though people in NCR have got some relief from the cold wave at present, but in spite of this Delhiites have been warned of a drop in temperature in ...
READ MORE
Women's T20 WC 2023: Indian captain Harmanpreet Kaur looked very disappointed after the semi-final defeat
Women's T20 World Cup 2023: The first semi-final of the Women's T20 World Cup 2023 was played between the women's teams of India and Australia. Kangaroo women's team defeated India ...
READ MORE
In Pics: Anant Ambani, Radhika Merchant All Smiles As They Pose With Family at Their Engagement
Ahead of the ceremony, the couple can be seen posing with their familyAnant Ambani, son of Reliance Industries Chairman Mukesh Ambani and wife Nita, is all set to get engaged ...
READ MORE
Palghar Gangrape: Overnight gang rape with a minor in Mumbai's Palghar, police arrested 8 accused
By-NareshA case of gang rape with a minor has come to light in Palghar, Maharashtra. Police has arrested 8 accused in this case. At the same time, the victim told ...
READ MORE
If you also have sugar, then definitely include these things in your diet.
It is not easy to control rising sugar. For this, one has to keep a close watch on the diet. Also, daily exercise is necessary. This disease is caused due ...
READ MORE
Turkey once again struck by earthquake, cracks in
In Cuttack, a stepmother murders her 2-year-old child
‘Bhabiji Ghar Par Hain’ fame Saumya Tandon was
Sukesh Chandrasekhar ruined my life, ruined my career,
Assam CM Sarma said – More than 4000
Be careful if you see these symptoms in
Women’s T20 WC 2023: Indian captain Harmanpreet Kaur
In Pics: Anant Ambani, Radhika Merchant All Smiles
Palghar Gangrape: Overnight gang rape with a minor
If you also have sugar, then definitely include
https://english.n27news.in /wp-content/uploads/2022/12/Capture-3.jpghttps://english.n27news.in /wp-content/uploads/2022/12/Capture-3-150x150.jpgN27 NewsNationalKerala HC,n27news.in,Right To Be Forgotten| Protection Of Personal Information Cannot Co-Exist In Open Court Justice System: Kerala HCBy-Naresh The Kerala High Court has held that a claim for the protection of personal information based on the right to privacy cannot co-exist in an Open Court justice system. Right To Be Forgotten| Protection Of Personal Information Cannot Co-Exist In Open Court Justice System: Kerala HC Court said the Open Court...Pakad Har Khabar Par